Elk Lotus LEDCommercial lighting specification, retrofit and acceptance

Section

Metrics & standards

How the numbers on a datasheet are defined, measured and misread — illuminance, glare, colour rendering, flicker and photometric files.

A datasheet number is the output of a procedure

Every figure on a luminaire datasheet — lumens, Ra, UGR, L70, a flicker percentage — is the result of a defined measurement carried out under defined conditions. The procedure is what the number means, and two numbers produced by different procedures do not compare even when they carry the same unit and the same name.

Most specification arguments we get drawn into come from that gap rather than from a supplier being dishonest. An LM-80 dataset describes bare LED packages held at a fixed case temperature on a test board. An LM-79 report describes an assembled luminaire, thermals and driver losses included. Both are legitimate; quoting a package lifetime as a luminaire lifetime is a category error, and it is the single most common one in this industry.

What each metric deliberately leaves out

The useful question about a metric is not what it measures but what it was designed not to measure. Ra averages the first eight test colours, all of them low-saturation pastels, which is why a source can post Ra 90 and still render saturated red badly — R9 sits outside the average and has to be asked for separately. Tabular UGR is computed for a standard reference room with defined surface reflectances; your room is not that room, and a catalogue "UGR<19" is a property of the test geometry as much as of the fitting. Flicker splits into two phenomena with two separate metrics and two separate limits, because the frequency band that causes visible fluctuation is not the band that freezes rotating machinery.

Illuminance carries the same trap in a different form. EN 12464-1 specifies maintained illuminance — the value the installation must still deliver at the end of the maintenance cycle — while catalogue calculations are routinely presented as initial. The gap between them is the maintenance factor, and a maintenance factor is not one number but a product of four: lamp lumen maintenance, lamp survival, luminaire maintenance and room surface maintenance. A specification that quotes a single illuminance figure with no reference plane, no uniformity requirement and no stated MF has not specified anything that can be verified on site.

How to use this section

The pages below take one metric each and do the same three things: state which document defines it, describe the measurement conditions it assumes, and show the specific way it gets misread in a tender. Where a standard governs the value we name the document and the clause rather than reproducing its tables, because those tables are licensed, they are revised, and a number transcribed onto a web page is a number nobody updates afterwards.